New York Yankees dealing with critical injury concern to starting rotation

The New York Yankees are grappling with a series of injuries that have significantly impacted their starting rotation as they prepare for the upcoming 2025 MLB season. These setbacks pose challenges to the team’s pitching depth and overall competitiveness.

Luis Gil’s Shoulder Tightness

A primary concern is the health of right-hander Luis Gil, who experienced shoulder tightness during a bullpen session on February 28, 2025. The session was halted prematurely due to his inability to loosen up, prompting the team to schedule an MRI to assess the severity of the issue. This development is particularly alarming given Gil’s history; he underwent Tommy John surgery in May 2022 but made a remarkable comeback to clinch the American League Rookie of the Year title in 2024, boasting a 15-7 record and a 3.50 ERA. Manager Aaron Boone expressed concern over Gil’s condition, acknowledging the potential impact on the rotation. citeturn0news17

JT Brubaker’s Rib Fractures

Adding to the Yankees’ woes, right-hander JT Brubaker suffered three fractured ribs after being struck by a comebacker during a game on February 21, 2025. Brubaker, who hasn’t pitched in the majors since 2022 due to Tommy John surgery in April 2023, was anticipated to be a valuable asset this season. His injury further depletes the team’s pitching options and underscores the challenges the Yankees face in maintaining a robust rotation. citeturn0news17

Chase Hampton’s Tommy John Surgery

The Yankees’ pitching depth took another hit with the loss of prospect Chase Hampton, who underwent season-ending Tommy John surgery after a complete tear of his right ulnar collateral ligament. Hampton had been dealing with partial tears and persistent discomfort, leading to the decision for surgery. Despite the setback, Hampton expressed a sense of relief, viewing the procedure as an opportunity to fully heal and return stronger in the future. His absence not only affects the current roster but also impacts the organization’s long-term pitching prospects. citeturn0news23

Gerrit Cole’s New Arsenal

Amid these challenges, there are positive developments. Ace Gerrit Cole showcased a new changeup during his first Grapefruit League outing against the Blue Jays, signaling a potential enhancement to his pitching repertoire. After dealing with elbow issues in the previous year, Cole’s performance—pitching 3 1/3 innings, allowing one run, and striking out five—was encouraging. The effective use of his changeup, previously thrown only 4% of the time last season, suggests it may become a significant weapon in his arsenal this year. Both Manager Aaron Boone and catcher Austin Wells expressed optimism about Cole’s refined pitch, viewing it as a positive development for the team’s rotation. citeturn0news18

Giancarlo Stanton’s Elbow Issues

While not a pitcher, designated hitter Giancarlo Stanton’s health status indirectly affects the team’s dynamics. Stanton is set to begin the season on the injured list due to tennis elbow in both arms. Despite playing through these injuries last season, the condition has worsened, preventing him from swinging a bat for several weeks. The team has not established a timetable for his return, emphasizing the need for Stanton to fully recover before rejoining the lineup. His absence necessitates adjustments in the batting order and may place additional pressure on the pitching staff to compensate for potential offensive shortfalls. citeturn0news21

Historical Injury Challenges

The Yankees’ rotation has faced injury challenges in recent years. In 2023, offseason acquisition Carlos Rodón started the regular season on the injured list due to a forearm strain, highlighting the fragility of the rotation. Similarly, in 2024, Nestor Cortés Jr. struggled with a left rotator cuff strain, leading to multiple stints on the injured list and eventually ending his season prematurely. These historical injuries underscore the ongoing challenges the Yankees face in maintaining a healthy and effective starting rotation. citeturn0search12turn0search27

Implications for the 2025 Season

The current injury concerns necessitate strategic adjustments by the Yankees’ management. The potential absence of key pitchers like Gil and Brubaker may lead to opportunities for other players, such as Marcus Stroman, to step into the rotation. However, this also means increased pressure on remaining healthy starters to deliver consistent performances. The team may need to explore external options or rely on emerging talent from their farm system to fill the gaps. Additionally, the offense will need to compensate for Stanton’s absence, requiring other hitters to elevate their contributions.

Conclusion

The Yankees are entering the 2025 season with significant injury-related challenges, particularly within their starting rotation. The health and performance of pitchers like Gerrit Cole, along with the timely return of injured players, will be crucial in determining the team’s success. Addressing these issues proactively and adapting to the evolving circumstances will be essential for the Yankees to remain competitive in the upcoming season.

navlistYankees Grapple with Injuries Ahead of 2025 Seasonturn0news17,turn0news21,turn0news23