Adam O’Brien’s departure as Newcastle Knights head coach in August 2025 marked the end of a six-year tenure that began with optimism but ultimately unraveled after a dismal season. The decision to part ways was mutual, though pressure had been mounting for months as the club’s form deteriorated and off-field distractions intensified.
O’Brien, who had been contracted through 2027, cited a Round 20 loss to the Warriors—sealed by a late Leka Halasima try—as the moment he realized his voice no longer resonated with the team. “I haven’t been able to pump them up again,” he admitted, reflecting on a stretch of heavy defeats that left the squad deflated and his position untenable. The Knights sat near the bottom of the NRL ladder with only six wins, plagued by injuries, inconsistent halves combinations, and an attack that produced nearly 100 fewer points than any other side.
Beyond results, there were growing concerns over internal harmony and leadership. Speculation about star fullback Kalyn Ponga’s future—rumors of a code switch to rugby union—added to the instability, while the board reportedly had contingency clauses that could have allowed them to terminate O’Brien’s contract based on performance.
Despite the poor finish, O’Brien’s overall record had its positives. He guided Newcastle to the finals in four of his six seasons and was at the helm during a memorable 10-game winning streak in 2023. However, the team never became a genuine premiership threat, and as form declined in 2025, it became clear that a new direction was needed.
Attention now turns to finding a successor. Assistant coach Blake Green is a candidate, though the Knights’ attacking struggles may count against him. Former Titans coach Justin Holbrook, with local ties and NRL experience, is considered a strong option. Others linked include Brian McDermott, Brad Arthur, and Willie Peters. Football director Peter Parr will lead the search, with a view to appointing someone capable of reinvigorating a club that has drifted.
In the end, O’Brien’s exit was as much about timing as it was results. He recognized the need for change before the pressure became toxic, departing with dignity and leaving the Knights to reset ahead of 2026. The challenge now is ensuring that reset leads to lasting improvement, not another cycle of unmet expectations.
