Newcastle Knights’ coaching situation:
—
Matty Johns’ Take on the Knights’ Coaching Search
1. A Left‑Field Option: Brian McDermott
Johns pointed to Brian McDermott, an English assistant coach already with the club, as a standout but often overlooked candidate. He believes McDermott has dramatically improved Newcastle’s defense—lifting them to be among the top five or six defensive teams in the NRL this year . Johns argued McDermott’s simple, effective methods make him “highly respected amongst the players,” and he noted Newcastle has history of success under an English coach (referencing Malcolm Reilly) .
2. Two Leading Contenders
Johns also named two high-profile figures as realistic frontrunners for the role:
Willie Peters – currently overseas and known for his coaching success and tactical acumen.
Justin Holbrook – another prominent coach in the mix, with notable credentials .
He even mentioned Michael Cheika as a potential “big risk” hire, given his rugby union background, though seeing such an appointment as unconventional .
—
Summary Snapshot
Category Names Commentary
Left‑Field Option Brian McDermott (assistant) Lauded for shoring up defense and strong rapport with players; a homegrown option.
Leading Contenders Willie Peters, Justin Holbrook Recognized coaching talents, likely the favorites for a mainstream appointment.
Wildcard Considered Michael Cheika Union background makes him a bold, high-risk choice—but Johns acknowledges the potential.
