The Philadelphia Phillies have come under criticism for failing to sign Bo Bichette, especially as concerns continue to grow over top prospect Aidan Miller’s health. Over the last several months, Miller—widely regarded as one of the organization’s most important young talents and a key part of the club’s long-term plans—has been dealing with a lingering back issue that has slowed his development.
Because of the injury, Miller has not yet returned to action in the minor leagues. He was unable to participate in spring training games and had previously missed the Arizona Fall League, where the Phillies had hoped he would gain valuable extra experience and continue progressing toward the majors.
Some analysts now believe Philadelphia’s front office may have mishandled the situation by not securing Bichette when they had the opportunity. Reports and speculation suggested the Phillies had interest in signing him, but no deal was ultimately completed.
According to FanSided’s Stephen Parello, bringing in Bichette could have triggered a larger roster reshuffle, potentially leading to Alec Bohm being traded as he approaches free agency. If that had happened, the Phillies’ strategy would likely have shifted toward allowing Miller to gradually prepare for a shot at the third base position in 2027. The organization had hoped the soon-to-be 22-year-old would spend this season gaining experience and positioning himself for that future opportunity.
Instead, Miller’s recurring back soreness has created uncertainty around those plans. The issue first surfaced last season, forced him to miss the Arizona Fall League, then sidelined him again during spring training. Even with some cautiously optimistic updates regarding his recovery, doubts remain about how quickly he can get back on track.
Had Bichette joined Philadelphia, Miller may have had less immediate pressure and a more flexible path toward debuting in either 2026 or 2027. Now, with the injury setbacks continuing, the Phillies’ decision not to add another proven infielder appears more questionable in hindsight.
Many believe the Phillies should have pursued Bichette more aggressively while still maintaining confidence in Miller’s future upside. Although the back problem is concerning, Miller is still young, and there remains plenty of time for him to recover and develop into the player the organization expects him to become.
